Home / Blog / Three Critically Injured in a North Phoe

Three Critically Injured in a North Phoenix Two-Car Crash: Who Pays When Fault Is Still Unresolved

12 News reported that three people were in critical condition after a two-car crash in north Phoenix. According to the outlet, the crash happened near Sweetwater Avenue and 32nd Street. No determination of fault has been reported, and no one has been charged with or convicted of anything.

When two vehicles collide and several people are left in critical condition, Arizona law does not require anyone to know who was at fault before a claim begins. Fault is decided later, by an insurer or a jury, and under A.R.S. § 12-2505 Arizona applies pure comparative fault; a person found partly responsible can still recover damages, reduced by their own percentage of fault. That rule matters most when a police investigation is open and each driver's insurer is blaming the other. Deadlines run regardless. A.R.S. § 12-542 gives two years from the date of injury to file suit, and if a government entity or employee is involved, A.R.S. § 12-821.01 requires a written notice of claim within 180 days. Critically injured occupants often face medical bills that exceed the at-fault driver's liability limits, which makes underinsured motorist coverage on any policy in the household worth checking immediately.

Pure Comparative Fault Means Nobody Is Automatically Shut Out

A.R.S. § 12-2505 is one of the more forgiving fault rules in the country. There is no bar at 50 percent. A driver assigned 70 percent of the fault can still recover 30 percent of their damages. Passengers are rarely assigned any fault at all, which means an injured passenger in either vehicle generally has a claim against one driver, the other, or both.

Expect an adjuster to float a fault percentage early, often before the police report is finished. That number is an opening position, not a finding. It is not binding on you, and it is frequently revised once the physical evidence, vehicle damage patterns, and any independent witness statements are reviewed. Do not accept a percentage assignment, and do not give a recorded statement about how a collision happened, before you have seen the report yourself.

When Injuries Are Critical, Coverage Runs Out Fast

Arizona's minimum liability limits are low relative to the cost of a critical-care hospitalization. When three people are seriously hurt in the same collision, one policy may have to be split among all of them, and it can be exhausted within days of admission. Practical steps that matter in the first two weeks:

  • Find every policy that might apply. Check the uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on the injured person's own auto policy and on the policy of any relative living in the same home. UIM often becomes the largest source of recovery in a severe-injury crash.
  • Give health insurance to the hospital. Using health coverage does not waive anything; the plan may later assert a reimbursement right out of a settlement, which is negotiable.
  • Preserve the vehicles. Ask that your car not be sold, crushed, or repaired until it has been inspected and photographed. Event data recorder information can be lost permanently when a vehicle is disposed of.
  • Keep a plain record. Dates of surgery, days in the ICU, equipment at home, and work missed by family members providing care are all documentable, and memory fades.

If a Loved One Does Not Survive

Critical condition is not an outcome, and the legal framework changes if an injured person later dies. Arizona's wrongful death statutes, A.R.S. § 12-611 through A.R.S. § 12-613, allow a surviving spouse, child, parent, or the estate to bring a claim for the survivors' own losses, including grief and lost companionship. Separately, A.R.S. § 14-3110 preserves the claim the injured person had while alive, which covers medical expenses and conscious pain and suffering before death. These are two distinct claims arising from one event, and families sometimes pursue only one because nobody explained the other. Both are subject to the same two-year deadline under A.R.S. § 12-542, measured from the date of death for the wrongful death claim.

If you or a family member was involved in this collision, our Phoenix car accident attorneys can explain what coverage applies before the first adjuster call.